ADVERTISMENT
 
 
9 Feb 2010
Marc's Blog
Marc's Blog
UK Wi-Fi Scandal - 8 Jul 2007

Wi-Fi in the UK is prominent, offered by cafes, bars, book stores and very often found in schools.

Commonly used to wirelessly connect to the Internet, Wi-Fi hit the headlines when the BBC programme Panorama found that radiation levels from Wi-Fi in one school was up to three times the level of mobile phone radiation, and implied that this was very dangerous to your health, without any evidence to support it.

Panorama’s classroom experiment was hardly scientific, and indeed provided the students a great lesson in how not to do a science experiment. The school even banned the TV crew when it found out about the bad science being conducted.

So what was wrong with this experiment? Well, in order to make sure that they could obtain the very highest Wi-Fi signal possible, the Panorama team started downloading the biggest file they could, despite the fact that the students are never allowed to download such files, and only use their laptops a couple of times a week.

As the readings were being taken, the teacher googled the name of the man who designed the equipment being used. Turns out that the equipment was built by Alasdair Philips, a man who campaigns against Wi-Fi and sells protective equipment against it. Not surprisingly, the readings were “well into the red”, but never explained!

One of the experts presented was Associate Professor Olle Johansson, awarded Misleader Of The Year 2004 in Sweden for his scaremongering regarding electromagnetic fields!

The peak readings were 600 times below the government’s safety limits, and UK experts in the field have spent much of their time recently denouncing the show and distancing themselves from the findings.


There is a nice take on it all at Bad Science


The Mr Science Show PodcastMr Science Stories

 

Have your say
 
There is plenty of evidence of health problems to support the - correct - claims within the BBC's Panorama programme.

Resorting to the personal level of attacks on the integrity of Dr. Olle Johannssen by referring to an award by the pseudo-skeptic group in Sweden, who are indirectly funded by big business interests, is the sort of level that the wireless industry is stooping to. Bad Science in the UK is closely aligned with such pseudo-skeptic groups.

If you want to see the actual non-experts who have commented on the program (not the 'UK experts in the field' that you claim) have a look at them at http://www.mastsanity.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=134&Itemid=1

For more background facts have a look at my own blog at http://mastsanity.blogspot.com/2007/06/bendetta-very-bad-science.html )

Schools and individuals in the UK are rightly ripping out their wi-fi systems and replacing them with wired networks. A safe approach and one I applaud.

Posted by: StayWired - 2007-07-17 - 15:03 GMT

Post new comment
Please copy the 5 symbols from this security code image into the box below to submit comment.

I agree to terms and conditions       

Posted by Marc


 
FirstScience.com

About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions
© 1995-2010 All rights reserved

About me
Name:
West, Marc
Marc West is a 27 year old Sydney-sider who has a passion for science, sport, travelling and particularly enjoys science communication. At...
Archives

Subscribe to Our Blog feed
Click the RSS icon to keep up with the latest postings from the Firstscience Bloggers

Why is science important?
Democratic process
Environment
Medicine
Technology
Understanding the Universe